Best Dog Treats for Aggressive Chewers

Britt
by Britt
Manfred Antranias Zimmer/pixabay

If you share your heart with a heavy chewer, you know that investing in normal treats, toys, and dog chews is like throwing money out the window. Treats that are said to entertain a dog for hours are gone in the blink of an eye. Luckily, some companies have gone out of their way to develop treats with these chew-happy dogs in mind.


When selecting a treat for your aggressive chewer, there are a few important factors you want to consider. How long will the treat last? Are the treats healthy for your dog to ingest? Is there a chance that they can get a piece off and choke? You may even be surprised to learn that some of the most common solutions for spoiling your aggressive chewer could be detrimental to their health.


To help you make an informed decision when shopping for your pup, we have put together this list of the best dog treats for aggressive chewers. Plus, we’ve included a guide to help you manage your heavy chewer and their need to gnaw!

Editors Choice: Earth Animal No-Hide Peanut Butter Natural Rawhide Alternative Dog Chew

If you are looking for a healthy alternative to traditional rawhide, the Earth Animal No-Hide chews are a great solution. They are made from all-natural ingredients, creating a low-fat and low-calorie chew that your dog will love to gnaw on. Each chew is hand-rolled and baked in Lancaster County, PA. If peanut butter isn’t a win, you can choose from several other flavors, including chicken, beef, venison, pork, and salmon.

Pros

  • Low-calorie treat for guilt-free chewing
  • Highly digestible to prevent GI issues
  • Available in a variety of sizes and flavors

Cons

  • Higher price point
  • Don’t last as long as some other options on the list

Runner-Up: Natural Farm Bully Sticks

Dog owners searching for a long-lasting chew for aggressive chewing dogs have likely heard about bully sticks. These single-ingredient treats are an excellent choice for dogs with allergies or sensitive stomachs, as they are easily digestible and free from all the additives and fillers. Natural Farm Bully Sticks don’t splinter during chewing as bones can.

Pros

  • Made from 100% grass-fed beef pizzle
  • Available in different sizes to accommodate large and small dogs
  • Single-ingredient treat

Cons

  • High price point
  • Some customers report a very unpleasant odor in some packages

Best Dental treat for Aggressive Chewers: Blue Buffalo Wilderness Wild Bones Grain Free Dental Chews

While many dental treats are gone in a matter of seconds, these dental chews from Blue Buffalo hold up surprisingly well for even the heavier chewers. They are grain free and made from high-quality, natural ingredients to offer your dog a safe and healthy dental care option. As your dog chews on the bone, they will work to reduce plaque and tartar, improve gum health, and freshen their breath.

Pros

  • Available in different sizes to accommodate large and small dogs
  • Clean your dog’s teeth while they are chewing
  • Grain-free recipe for dogs with allergies

Cons

  • Don’t last as long as some other options on the list
  • Become too hard for safe chewing if left out of the package too long

Best Yak Cheese Treat for Heavy Chewers: EcoKind Pet Treats Premium Gold Himalayan Yak Cheese Dog Ch

These delicious chews are made from 100% yak and cow’s milk, processed to remove Lactose. This, along with being gluten-free, makes them easily digestible and good for dogs with sensitive stomachs. The chews themselves are a hard texture that encourages your dog to chew happily while they stand up to even the most intense chewers. When you get to the last little piece, they can be microwaved to blow up, like popcorn, for a tasty extra treat.

Pros

  • Gluten, grain, and lactose-free for sensitive stomachs
  • All natural ingredients free from chemicals and additives
  • Company offers a 100% money-back guarantee

Cons

  • They can splinter during chewing
  • Some customers report the treats are inconsistent in size and quality

Best Budget Treat for Heavy Chewers: Nutri Chomps Easy to Digest Rawhide-Free Dog Chews

The costs of owning a dog can add up fast! If you’re looking to provide your aggressive chewer with something a little special without breaking the bank, Nutri Chomps are a good option. They are available in different flavors, or you can purchase the mixed pack here, which includes chicken, peanut butter, and the original milk flavor. The chews are high in protein, easy to digest, rawhide-free, vitamin and mineral enriched, and braided for extra durability.

Pros

  • Fortified with 7 essential vitamins and minerals
  • Available in a variety of sizes and flavors
  • Budget-friendly price

Cons

  • Don’t last as long as some other options on the list
  • Customers warn they can cause GI issues in dogs with sensitive stomachs

Best treat for Aggressive Chewing Senior Dogs: Redbarn Beef Collagen Sticks for Dogs

When selecting a treat for your senior dog, some treats offer great health benefits to support them through the aging process. Redbarn Beef Collagen Sticks are naturally packed with collagen peptides, chondroitin, and glucosamine, all of which help to support joint health and improve mobility. Redbarn also offers rings, braids, and twists made from the same recipe if you are interested in something a little more interesting visually.

Pros

  • Natural collagen supports joint, skin & coat health
  • Contain chondroitin and glucosamine
  • Available in different sizes to accommodate large and small dogs

Cons

  • They can splinter during chewing
  • Customers report the texture/harness varies from package to package

Best treat for Heavy Chewing Small Dogs: Nature Gnaws Braided Bully Sticks for Dogs

Whether your dog is an aggressive chewer isn’t directly related to their size. There are many heavy chewers in smaller fury packages that also need a more durable option. These braided bully sticks from Nature Gnaws are a single-ingredient, rawhide-free treat you can feel good about giving your dog. The braided design adds to the longevity while helping to scrape any plaque or tartar off their teeth as they chew.

Pros

  • 6-inch length is perfect for small or medium breed dogs
  • 100% natural, single-ingredient recipe
  • Natural beef smell and flavor to keep your dog interested

Cons

  • They can’t easily be broken for tiny or toy breeds
  • Size of individual chews is inconsistent from package to package

Best Dog Chew Toy for Aggressive Chewers: KONG Extreme Dental Durable Natural Rubber Dog Bone

While this natural rubber dog bone from KONG isn’t actually a treat, it is made for aggressive chewers and can be filled with treats as a safe alternative. The toy features KONG’s Denta-Ridges, a texture designed to clean your dog’s teeth and gums while chewing. The Extreme line of KONG toys is extra durable, made with the heaviest chewers in mind. Pair it with smaller treats, kibble, or a spreadable treat to keep your dog occupied for an extended time.

Pros

  • Reusable making it a budget-friendly investment
  • Can be used to make mealtime more engaging, perfect for dogs on a diet
  • Available in a variety of sizes and shapes

Cons

  • May not interest dog without pairing it with treats (purchased separately)
  • Ridges can make it challenging to clean and disinfect

Do Dogs Outgrow Chewing?


If your aggressive chewer is currently a puppy, you may wonder, will my dog outgrow this need to gnaw on something? There is no way to know. Some dogs will enjoy chewing as young pups to help with teething and excess puppy energy. But they show little to no interest in the activity as a mature adult. There are also many dogs that will continue enjoying a good chew throughout their lives.


Starting from the puppy stage, ensure that you provide plenty of chew-friendly toys and treats. If you notice your dog chewing on something they shouldn’t, like your tennis shoes, redirect them to an appropriate chewing option. Doing this will train them to focus their chewing on approved items as they grow up.


Is it Safe for Dogs to Chew on Sticks?


Sticks are a natural option, but many veterinarians warn against allowing dogs to chew on them. As simple as they may seem, sticks and random pieces of wood may set your dog up for trouble.


Small pieces and slivers can easily break off a stick while going unnoticed. These slivers can become trapped between the teeth, in your dog’s gums, or in the top of their mouth between their teeth. Wood slivers and smaller wedged sticks can be very painful. The longer they remain trapped in your dog’s mouth, the more damage they can cause, including infections, abscesses, ulcers, and other injuries. In more severe cases, teeth may need to be extracted due to damage.


Do Vets Approve or Rawhide?


Rawhide bones were once considered the perfect option for heavy-chewing dogs because they are durable and budget-friendly. However, new information has revealed that rawhide isn’t the safe and enjoyable treat it was once believed to be. Today, many veterinarians will encourage dog owners to steer clear of rawhide in favor of safer rawhide-free alternatives like those included on this list.


The biggest concern with rawhide bones is that rawhide doesn’t completely break down in your dog’s digestive tract. If your dog were to break off and swallow a piece, it is a gamble whether it will safely pass it or cause a stomach or intestinal obstruction. Blockages in the digestive tract can quickly turn life-threatening and require expensive surgery to address and treat.


Other concerns relating to rawhide include:

  • Choking hazard from pieces getting lodged in the throat
  • GI upset from the foreign body in the stomach even if there is no blockage
  • Chemicals used in the processing of rawhide

Can Dog Chews Be Too Hard?


When choosing dog treats for an aggressive chewer, we often look for the harder, more durable treats. But can these treats be too hard? The short answer is yes! Treats that are too hard or rigid for your dog can cause the teeth to chip or be damaged while chewing.


The rule of thumb for dog treats and toys is that they should be soft enough to leave an impression when you push your thumbnail into them. This doesn’t mean that your thumbnail can remove part of the chew or cause significant damage. But a mark should be left showing that it did “give a little” when the nail is pressed against it.


If your dog loves a treat that doesn’t pass the thumbnail test, you may be able to soften it by steaming the chew. Wrap the chew in a damp paper towel or cloth and place them on low heat in your microwave.


We are committed to finding, researching, and recommending the best products. We earn commissions from purchases you make using the retail links in our product reviews. Learn more about how this works.

Britt
Britt

Britt Kascjak is a proud pet mom, sharing her heart (and her home) with her “pack” which includes her husband John, their 2 dogs – Indiana and Lucifer – and their 2 cats – Pippen and Jinx. She has been active in the animal rescue community for over 15 years, volunteering, fostering and advocating for organizations across Canada and the US. In her free time, she enjoys traveling around the country camping, hiking, and canoeing with her pets.

More by Britt

Next